Clicky

Heating

How and Why New Heat Pumps Crush Space Heaters

Dave and Todd hook up an amp clamp to a space heater and a mini-split heat pump side by side to show exactly how much power each one draws for the same job. The numbers make the case for switching off resistive heat for good.

Jump to transcript

In this video

  • Live demo using an amp clamp compares real power draw: a 1,500-watt space heater pulling 12 amps versus a mini-split heat pump pulling as little as 5.5 amps
  • Space heaters convert electricity to heat one-for-one (1 watt in = 1 watt out); heat pumps move existing heat instead of generating it, so they output far more BTUs per watt
  • Explains the watts-to-BTU conversion (watts x 3.41) and shows the mini-split producing around 12,000 BTUs for a fraction of the amperage of the space heater
  • Covers how inverter compressors let modern heat pumps keep working down to around 14 degrees Fahrenheit, versus older on-off compressors that stalled out around 30-40 degrees
  • Introduces EVI (enhanced/evaporative vapor injection) technology, which lets newer heat pumps keep pulling heat even in extreme sub-zero temperatures
  • Ties it back to solar: pairing a heat pump with solar panels (like Airspool's setup) lets you run heating during the day essentially for free

Questions this video answers

Are heat pumps actually more efficient than space heaters?

Yes. In the video's amp-clamp test, a 1,500-watt space heater draws about 12 amps to produce roughly 5,100 BTUs, while an inverter mini-split heat pump produces about 12,000 BTUs on only about 5.5 amps. That's because a space heater converts electricity to heat one-for-one, while a heat pump moves existing heat using much less energy than it delivers.

How much electricity does a space heater use compared to a mini-split?

A typical 1,500-watt space heater runs at about 12 amps on a standard 120-volt circuit. In the same test, the mini-split heat pump was drawing only 500 to 800 watts (roughly 5.5 amps) to heat a comparable space, especially in mild outdoor temperatures.

How do you convert watts to BTUs for a heater?

Multiply the wattage by 3.41. So a 1,500-watt space heater outputs about 5,100 BTUs, since it converts power to heat at a strict one-to-one ratio with no efficiency gain.

Why can heat pumps produce more heat than the electricity they use?

A heat pump doesn't generate heat the way a space heater does; it moves heat using a refrigerant, compressor, and fans, similar to how a delivery truck can carry far more fuel than it burns to get there. That's why a heat pump can output several times more heat energy than the electrical energy it consumes.

Do heat pumps still work in cold winter weather?

Older on-off compressor heat pumps often stopped working effectively once outdoor temperatures dropped to around 30-40 degrees Fahrenheit. Modern inverter-compressor heat pumps, like the one shown in the video, can keep working down to around 14 degrees, and newer EVI (enhanced vapor injection) technology extends that performance down to 35-40 degrees below zero.

What is EVI in a heat pump?

EVI (enhanced/evaporative vapor injection) is newer heat pump technology that gets the refrigerant much colder on the outdoor unit, allowing the system to keep extracting heat from the outside air even in extreme sub-zero temperatures where older heat pumps would fail.

Should I ditch electric strip heat or space heaters?

The video argues yes: electric resistive heat, whether it's a plug-in space heater or electric strip heating in an HVAC system, is only as efficient as a one-to-one watt-to-heat conversion. A heat pump delivers the same or more warmth using a fraction of the electricity.

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than natural gas heat?

The video says it depends on local energy costs and is worth running the math on, since natural gas can sometimes win on cost when a heat pump is running purely off the grid. But pairing a heat pump with solar, as Airspool's systems do, lets you run heating for free during the day, which changes the comparison.

Transcript

Read the full transcript

Hey guys, Dave and Todd here. A lot of people assume that all electric heat is created equal, and that's not the case. Today we're going to be looking at this space heater here, and you see the amp clamp -- we're going to look at the amount of power coming in to power this, and the amount of energy going through this amp clamp here to power this inverter compressor mini-split, with a condenser and compressor up on the roof there.

Okay, so Todd, without further ado, we'll see up on your rooftop in a second. Let's start out talking about this unit right here. A lot of people have these in their basements or guest rooms -- wonderful in their simplicity. They take one watt of power in, they burn that watt in this resistive heat element, so it's one-for-one: one watt in gives you one watt out. And they're pretty much consistently rated at 1,500 watts. Why 1,500 watts? Well, that way you can plug them into a standard 15-amp breaker and stay under the limit. So this one right now is nicely running at 12 amps. 12 amps times 120 volts gives you around 1,500 watts.

So what does that mean in terms of BTUs? To get to BTUs you take the 1,500 watts and multiply that by 3.41 -- watts times 3.41 gives you BTUs. So this one's at 12 amps, and we can look at what the mini-split is doing too. That one right now is running at only 499 watts. Why? It reached its set point. Let's try and turn it up a little bit and you'll see the watts go up slightly -- probably peaking for right now at around 700 or 800 watts. That's because it's the last real day of winter here, and this morning it's 55 degrees in Las Vegas. The closer you are to 75 degrees, the less distance the heat pump has to move that heat, so it takes less power. This one seems pretty satisfied at around 600 to 700 watts, and that can be verified if we multiply it out. Okay, 5.5 amps versus 12 amps.

So what would you rather have: 12 amps for 5,100 BTUs, or 5.5 amps for 12,000 BTUs? Again, it's only using around 600 to 699 watts. As heat pumps get to a lower outdoor temperature, they do need a little more power, but nowhere close to what a space heater draws.

So why do heat pumps work the way they do, and how do they work? Heat pumps carry energy. Instead of just burning power like a space heater does, think of the motors in the heat pump -- the compressor up on the roof, the condenser fan, and the fan motor inside -- there are basically three fans total. Those fans move the refrigerant, and the refrigerant carries the heat. Think about it first in air conditioning mode, since that's a little simpler to picture: if it's 100 degrees outside in the summertime and I turn this on, that coil carries the heat out of the house because the refrigerant running through it is cold. You can imagine it like a delivery truck pulling up -- the truck itself only gets five miles a gallon, but it's carrying eight or ten thousand gallons of fuel. It's carrying a lot more energy than it's burning to get there, and that's conceptually what a heat pump does.

So it makes sense that in the summertime you're carrying heat out of the house, but how can that work in the wintertime when it's 20 degrees outside? That was the limitation of older heat pumps: if they only had simple on-off compressors, they'd stop working effectively once it got down to around 30 or 40 degrees, and that doesn't cut it for most of the country. Even here in Las Vegas, on a winter night it can get down to 28 degrees or so. But with the inverter compressor unit we have here, this system will keep working down to around 14 degrees.

And now there's something called EVI -- enhanced vapor injection. It's a newer technology, a little complicated to explain fully, but EVI is the next step in how heat pumps work: it lets you get the refrigerant much colder on the outdoor side, so the system can still pull in heat even when it's 35 to 40 degrees below zero Fahrenheit outside.

So here at Airspool, we talk about air conditioning, we talk about solar, and we talk about solar air conditioning. If you got anything out of this video, we appreciate the like, appreciate the comments, appreciate the subscription. Thanks for your time.

Written by Airspool Team

The crew that designs, tests, and ships every Airspool unit. We write the guides we wish we'd had when we started — plain-English, DIY-first, and honest about the tradeoffs.

Free download

What they're hoping you never read.

✓ It's yours.

Grab your copy right here, right now:

Download the guide (PDF) ▸

A copy is also on the way to your inbox.

Instant PDF download. Unsubscribe anytime.

The 7 Ugly Truths guide cover

Get the next guide in your inbox

Install tips, savings math, and straight answers. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

A couple enjoying a cozy autumn living room with an Airspool unit.Crisp days.
Cozy homes.

A LITTLE SOMETHING FOR YOUR NEXT SEASON

Fall into savings.

$100 off

Make yourself comfortable. Join our email list and we’ll send your Fall discount code.

$100 off orders of $1,500 or more. Merchandise subtotal before tax and shipping. One use per customer. Cannot be combined with other discount codes.